After more than 25 years of knitting, frogging knitting projects is still part of my creative process. Sometimes I unravel a few rows to fix a mistake. Sometimes it’s a sock cuff because I don’t like how the yarn looks. And sometimes it’s a project that has been sitting unfinished for 10 to 15 years that I finally admit I’m never going to finish.
If you’re unfamiliar with the term, “frogging” means ripping out your knitting. Rip it, rip it… ribbit. Knitters do love a good pun.
I still make mistakes, of course, but mistakes aren’t the only reason I frog. Sometimes I don’t like the fabric. Sometimes I’ve lost interest. Sometimes I want the yarn for something else. What has changed over the years is how I decide whether to keep going.
Frogging knitting projects that have had their chance
Before my move to Kansas, I went through some of my UFOs—unfinished objects—and frogged several that I had started 10 or 15 years ago, or even longer. At that point, I had to admit they weren’t going to get finished.

There was probably a reason I put each one aside in the first place. Whatever enthusiasm I had when I cast on hadn’t brought me back to it in all those years. Packing for a move was a good opportunity to ask whether I actually wanted to knit it anymore.
The answer, for a few of them, was no. Unraveling those projects meant the yarn could go back into my stash with the possibility of becoming something I would enjoy making now.
A pretty skein doesn’t always make a sock I like
Other projects don’t need years before I make that decision. I’ve frogged several pairs of socks after knitting just a few inches of the cuff because I didn’t like how the yarn was knitting up.

Yarn can look wonderful in the skein and turn into fabric that doesn’t appeal to me. Sometimes you have to knit a little to find out. If I’m already unhappy with it at the cuff, there’s a good chance knitting an entire sock—and then a second one—won’t improve my opinion.
Those few inches have told me something useful. I can try another pattern or save the yarn for a different project.
Choosing what to carry forward
I’ve also been going through my mom’s basement now that she’s in assisted living. It holds more than 35 years of knitting and crafting supplies, including over 100 started projects. Many still have their patterns, needles, and notions together.
My mom taught me to knit, so sorting through her projects has a different meaning than going through my own stash. I’ve taken some home to finish, but most of the remaining unfinished pieces were cut and put in textile recycling. The unused yarn was sold or added to my stash.

That wasn’t technically frogging, but it brought up the same question: which projects did I want to take home and finish?
Having the pattern and supplies together doesn’t mean a project has to be completed. I can choose some of my mom’s work to carry forward without taking on every unfinished project in the basement.
Some mistakes are worth ripping back for
Then there are the times I frog because I made a mistake. Yes, after all these years, that still happens.
My deciding factor is usually whether I can live with it. If I know it’s going to bother me whenever I look at the finished piece, I’ll rip back and fix it. Other times, I decide I’m comfortable leaving it and keep knitting.
That decision can be different from one project to the next. I don’t need every piece of knitting to be perfect, but I do want to enjoy what I’ve made.
Sometimes I start with the unraveling
I’ve even purchased knitted sweaters at thrift stores specifically to frog them and reuse the yarn. In those cases, unraveling is part of the plan from the beginning. A finished sweater becomes the materials for something new.

I like that possibility when I look at an old project, too. It might still become the thing I originally intended. It might become something completely different.
After 25 years of knitting, I still frog things because I still make mistakes, change my mind, and discover that some ideas work better than others. I’ve learned that starting a project doesn’t mean I have to finish it. The time I’ve already spent on it can help me decide what I want to do next.
What makes you decide a project is worth finishing—or ready to frog?
